Repair or Replace a Flat Tire: How the Damage Decides
Where the puncture is, how big the hole is, whether the tire was driven flat, and its age and wear decide repair or replace. Why a plug alone falls short.

Repair or Replace: How the Damage Decides
Not every flat means a new tire, and not every flat can be saved. These are the factors that decide it.
Where the Puncture Is
Only damage in the tread area, the flat part that meets the road, can be repaired. The shoulder, where the tread curves into the sidewall, and the sidewall itself are off limits. They flex with every turn of the wheel, and no patch holds up under that. A tire with sidewall damage must be replaced.
How Big the Hole Is
The usual repair limit for a puncture is about a quarter inch (6 mm), roughly the width of a pencil. A nail or screw hole is normally well inside that. A gash, a tear or a hole bigger than the limit means replacement.
Whether the Tire Was Driven Flat
A tire driven flat, even a short distance, can have its inner liner and sidewall chewed up from the inside, and that damage is invisible from outside. That is the most common reason a repairable puncture turns into a replacement.
Age, Wear and Multiple Holes
A tire already worn to its wear bars, or cracked with age, is not worth repairing, since it is finished anyway. Check its DOT date code if you are unsure how old it is. Two holes can be repaired only if they are far enough apart that the repairs do not overlap; several close together usually mean replacement.
Why a Plug on Its Own Falls Short
A plug pushed in from the outside gets a car moving, but on its own it is not a complete repair. A proper repair is made from the inside, so the tire has to come off the wheel. That is the only way to see what the object did to the inner liner and to seal the hole correctly. Treat an outside-only plug as temporary.
For more on what can be saved and what cannot, see our flat tire repair page.
Frequently Asked Questions
No. The sidewall flexes constantly, and no repair holds there safely. That tire needs to be replaced.
Not Sure What Your Tire Needs?
If you are not sure what your tire needs, contact us or read about our flat tire repair.